New Eatery At Former Brother Bruno's Now Open Near Bethel, NY

Mooove over, there's a new cow in town. Sullivan County residents can now see a pretty cow statue in all of her glory at a new, groovy eatery in the area.

An exciting new business has taken over the former, Brother Bruno's on 17 B in Sullivan County.

What Did Brother Bruno's Bring To The Sullivan County, NY Community?

Brother Bruno's was a fan-favorite restaurant in Sullivan County. This restaurant served Italian cuisine and was known for its signature pizzas which locals enjoyed.

On September 1, 2023, Brother Bruno's of Monticello made a post on social media. Hudson Valley residents and Facebook users shared their opinions about this favorite restaurant stating that they were closing their doors.

Brother Brunos of Monticello shared,

"Brother Bruno‘s is permanently closed"

"Want to say thank you to our regular customers for supporting us throughout the years.

We’re going to miss you guys. Thank you"

In January 2024, Brother Bruno's of Monticello, NY was for sale. Information and pictures were provided by Keller Williams Hudson Valley and Coldwell Banker Realty of the property.

In 2024, signs of a new business in the former Brother Bruno's location were noticed by locals along with a groovy cow statue.

What Groovy New Eatery Took Over Brother Bruno's In Sullivan County, NY?

Originally, there was a sign on site and information on social media about this new business. I saw Woodstock Way Groovy Eatery and Cafe would soon take over the former Brother Bruno's location on 17 B.

Guests can now visit The Woodstock Way Groovy Eatery in the former Brother Bruno's location.

SEE MORE: Roadside Attraction Scavenger Hunt Through Sullivan County, NY

The Woodstock Way Groovy Eatery Is Now Open In The Hudson Valley

It's possible that the Woodstock Way Groovy Eatery has three names. This new eatery is located in the former Brother Bruno's building on 17B in Sullivan County, NY.

However, Google refers to The Woodstock Way Groovy Eatery's location as Mongaup Valley, while their Facebook page says Bethel as the location and Brother Bruno's used Monticello as their location.

Foodies can visit this exciting new eatery at 951 NY-17B, Mongaup Valley, NY 12762. The Woodstock Way Groovy Eatery has a unique yet pretty cow statue outside of their business. With its ruby red lipstick, peace sign turquoise hat on, red scarf, flannel top and more, this cow draws all of the right attention to his new, groovy eatery.

Get our free mobile app

The Woodstock Way Groovy Eatery shared its menu on its website. Guests can enjoy options such as breakfast and lunch. They also have bakery and dessert goodies, drinks and a kids menu. Breakfast options such as an Electric egg sandwich, yasgur benedict and sizzling Santana are all available at The Woodstock Way Groovy Eatery.

Within a few miles of The Woodstock Way Groovy Eatery is Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, the original site of the 1969 Woodstock Music Festival. It makes sense that they are serving food options dedicated to the talented musicians who performed there in 1969.

Hendrix Heatwave, Richie Havens Veggie, and more lunch options are available on-site.

Additional information about Sullivan County, NY's newest, groovy eatery can be found on their website and with 94.3 Lite FM.

5 Must See Scenic Drives In The Hudson Valley

When was the last time that you took the scenic route or the back road? There's something so peaceful about taking in the views of the beautiful farmland and the smells of fresh grass with the windows down.

The next time that you're out for a drive, take one of these scenic routes to capture the beauty of the area that we get to call home.

SEE MORE: This Windy Hudson Valley Road Ranks 'One Of The Most Beautiful' In New York

Gallery Credit: Allison Kay

Take a Tour of Sullivan County, NY's Newest Underground Salt Cave

Crystal Connection is a 1890's antique, Methodist church located in Sullivan County, NY. This is a crystal lover's dream come true.

It's known for being

"One of the largest Crystal & Mineral destinations on the Northeast."

While this may be a place that some people gather often, others can refer to it as a hidden gem in the Hudson Valley. Crystal Connection can also be described as

"a sacred space & crystal haven"

I have never experienced anything similar to Crystal Connection before. The amount of crystals, crystal jewelry, singing bowls, sage and more are fascinating. Crystal Connection also hosts different events and fairs throughout the year.

Take a tour through Crystal Connection's newest underground salt cave experience.

Gallery Credit: Allison Kay, Crystal Connection, YouTube